fix(language): drop motion from VIEW_DEPENDENT_STYLES

Motion primitives are described in robot-frame (joint / Cartesian) terms,
not pixel space, so they are camera-agnostic. Only `vqa` (event) and
`trace` (event, pixel-trajectory) are view-dependent.

The `camera` field stays on PERSISTENT_ROW_FIELDS for schema symmetry —
the validator, resolver, and HF feature mapping behave identically across
the two columns regardless of which styles populate `camera` today —
but persistent rows now always have `camera=None` in practice.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

docs/source/language_and_recipes.mdx

@@ -6,16 +6,24 @@ The two optional columns are:
 - `language_persistent`: a list of rows broadcast across every frame in an episode for state that remains active, such as `subtask`, `plan`, and `memory`.
 - `language_events`: a list of rows only on the exact frame where an event was emitted, such as `interjection`, `vqa`, and speech tool calls.
 
-Both columns share the same row shape:
+Both columns share the same row shape (event rows omit `timestamp` because the
+frame the row sits on already provides it):
 
 ```text
 role: string
 content: string | null
 style: string | null
-timestamp: float64
+timestamp: float64        # persistent rows only
+camera: string | null     # observation.images.* feature key, view-dependent rows only
 tool_calls: list[Json] | null
 ```
 
+The `camera` field tags rows whose `content` is grounded in a specific camera
+view. Rows of view-dependent styles (`vqa`, and the reserved `motion` /
+`trace`) MUST set `camera` to the matching `observation.images.*` feature key.
+Rows of every other style MUST leave `camera` as `null`. Pipeline writers and
+the validator enforce this via `validate_camera_field(style, camera)`.
+
 `meta/tasks.parquet` remains the canonical source for the task. The special `${task}` recipe binding always reads that task string and does not depend on language annotations.
 
 ## Architecture
@@ -39,11 +47,37 @@ Persistent styles are active after emission until replaced:
 Event styles only exist on their exact timestamp:
 
 - `emitted_at(t, style=interjection)`
-- `emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=user)`
+- `emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=user, camera=observation.images.top)`
 - `emitted_at(t, role=assistant, tool_name=say)`
 
 Exact event matching has no tolerance window, so writers must stamp event rows with frame timestamps from the parquet data.
 
+## View-dependent resolution
+
+For view-dependent styles (`vqa`, `motion`, `trace`), the resolver gains a
+`camera=` filter parallel to `role=` and `tool_name=`. Datasets with multiple
+cameras typically emit one (`vqa`, `user`) + (`vqa`, `assistant`) pair per
+camera at the same timestamp; without `camera=`, those resolvers see two
+matches and raise an ambiguity error. Recipes consume each camera through its
+own binding plus a matching image block, e.g.
+
+```yaml
+ask_vqa_top:
+  bindings:
+    vqa_query: "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=user, camera=observation.images.top)"
+    vqa: "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=assistant, camera=observation.images.top)"
+  messages:
+    - role: user
+      stream: high_level
+      if_present: vqa_query
+      content:
+        - { type: image, feature: observation.images.top }
+        - { type: text, text: "${vqa_query}" }
+    - { role: assistant, content: "${vqa}", stream: high_level, target: true, if_present: vqa }
+```
+
+Add one such sub-recipe per camera the dataset records.
+
 ## Recipe anatomy
 
 Recipes are YAML files backed by `TrainingRecipe` and `MessageTurn`.

src/lerobot/configs/recipes/pi05_hirobot.yaml

@@ -40,8 +40,35 @@ blend:
       - {role: user, content: "${task}\nPlan: ${plan}\nMemory: ${memory}", stream: high_level}
       - {role: assistant, content: "${subtask}", stream: low_level, target: true}
 
-  ask_vqa:
-    weight: 0.20
+  # VQA is view-dependent: bbox / keypoint / count answers only make sense for
+  # the camera they were grounded against. Each camera gets its own sub-recipe
+  # so the resolver can disambiguate via `camera=...` and the user-turn carries
+  # the matching image block. Adjust the camera keys (and add more sub-recipes)
+  # to match the cameras present on your dataset.
+  ask_vqa_top:
+    weight: 0.10
+    bindings:
+      vqa_query: "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=user, camera=observation.images.top)"
+      vqa: "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=assistant, camera=observation.images.top)"
     messages:
-      - {role: user, content: "${vqa_query}", stream: high_level, if_present: vqa_query}
+      - role: user
+        stream: high_level
+        if_present: vqa_query
+        content:
+          - {type: image, feature: observation.images.top}
+          - {type: text, text: "${vqa_query}"}
+      - {role: assistant, content: "${vqa}", stream: high_level, target: true, if_present: vqa}
+
+  ask_vqa_wrist:
+    weight: 0.10
+    bindings:
+      vqa_query: "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=user, camera=observation.images.wrist)"
+      vqa: "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=assistant, camera=observation.images.wrist)"
+    messages:
+      - role: user
+        stream: high_level
+        if_present: vqa_query
+        content:
+          - {type: image, feature: observation.images.wrist}
+          - {type: text, text: "${vqa_query}"}
       - {role: assistant, content: "${vqa}", stream: high_level, target: true, if_present: vqa}

src/lerobot/datasets/language.py

@@ -24,8 +24,8 @@ import pyarrow as pa
 LANGUAGE_PERSISTENT = "language_persistent"
 LANGUAGE_EVENTS = "language_events"
 LANGUAGE_COLUMNS = (LANGUAGE_PERSISTENT, LANGUAGE_EVENTS)
-PERSISTENT_ROW_FIELDS = ("role", "content", "style", "timestamp", "tool_calls")
-EVENT_ROW_FIELDS = ("role", "content", "style", "tool_calls")
+PERSISTENT_ROW_FIELDS = ("role", "content", "style", "timestamp", "camera", "tool_calls")
+EVENT_ROW_FIELDS = ("role", "content", "style", "camera", "tool_calls")
 
 CORE_STYLES = {"subtask", "plan", "memory", "motion", "interjection", "vqa", "trace"}
 EXTENDED_STYLES = set()
@@ -34,6 +34,18 @@ STYLE_REGISTRY = CORE_STYLES | EXTENDED_STYLES
 PERSISTENT_STYLES = {"subtask", "plan", "memory", "motion"}
 EVENT_ONLY_STYLES = {"interjection", "vqa", "trace"}
 
+# Styles whose ``content`` is grounded in a specific camera view. Rows of these
+# styles MUST carry a non-null ``camera`` referencing an ``observation.images.*``
+# feature key. Rows of every other style MUST have ``camera=None``. ``motion``
+# is intentionally NOT in this set: motion primitives are described in
+# robot-frame (joint / Cartesian) terms, not pixel space, so they are
+# camera-agnostic. ``trace`` is the pixel-trajectory event style and IS
+# view-dependent. The ``camera`` field nevertheless lives on
+# ``PERSISTENT_ROW_FIELDS`` too so the schema, validator, and resolver
+# behave symmetrically across the two columns; persistent rows simply
+# always have ``camera=None`` in practice today.
+VIEW_DEPENDENT_STYLES = {"vqa", "trace"}
+
 LanguageColumn = Literal["language_persistent", "language_events"]
 
 
@@ -59,6 +71,7 @@ def language_persistent_row_arrow_type() -> pa.StructType:
             pa.field("content", pa.string(), nullable=True),
             pa.field("style", pa.string(), nullable=True),
             pa.field("timestamp", pa.float64(), nullable=False),
+            pa.field("camera", pa.string(), nullable=True),
             pa.field("tool_calls", pa.list_(_json_arrow_type()), nullable=True),
         ]
     )
@@ -75,6 +88,7 @@ def language_event_row_arrow_type() -> pa.StructType:
             pa.field("role", pa.string(), nullable=False),
             pa.field("content", pa.string(), nullable=True),
             pa.field("style", pa.string(), nullable=True),
+            pa.field("camera", pa.string(), nullable=True),
             pa.field("tool_calls", pa.list_(_json_arrow_type()), nullable=True),
         ]
     )
@@ -97,6 +111,7 @@ def language_persistent_row_feature() -> dict[str, object]:
         "content": datasets.Value("string"),
         "style": datasets.Value("string"),
         "timestamp": datasets.Value("float64"),
+        "camera": datasets.Value("string"),
         "tool_calls": datasets.List(_json_feature()),
     }
 
@@ -107,6 +122,7 @@ def language_event_row_feature() -> dict[str, object]:
         "role": datasets.Value("string"),
         "content": datasets.Value("string"),
         "style": datasets.Value("string"),
+        "camera": datasets.Value("string"),
         "tool_calls": datasets.List(_json_feature()),
     }
 
@@ -134,6 +150,30 @@ def is_language_column(key: str) -> bool:
     return key in LANGUAGE_COLUMNS
 
 
+def is_view_dependent_style(style: str | None) -> bool:
+    """Return ``True`` if rows of ``style`` must be tagged with a ``camera`` key."""
+    return style in VIEW_DEPENDENT_STYLES
+
+
+def validate_camera_field(style: str | None, camera: str | None) -> None:
+    """Enforce the ``camera`` invariant: required iff ``style`` is view-dependent.
+
+    Raises ``ValueError`` if a view-dependent style is missing ``camera`` or if
+    a non-view-dependent style carries one. Pipeline writers and the validator
+    should call this on every emitted row.
+    """
+    if is_view_dependent_style(style):
+        if not camera:
+            raise ValueError(
+                f"Rows of view-dependent style {style!r} require a non-empty 'camera' "
+                f"field referencing an 'observation.images.*' feature key."
+            )
+    elif camera is not None:
+        raise ValueError(
+            f"Rows of style {style!r} must have camera=None; got camera={camera!r}."
+        )
+
+
 def column_for_style(style: str | None) -> LanguageColumn:
     """Map a language style to the column where rows of that style are stored.
 

src/lerobot/datasets/language_render.py

@@ -46,18 +46,23 @@ def active_at(
     style: str | None = None,
     role: str | None = None,
     tool_name: str | None = None,
+    camera: str | None = None,
 ) -> LanguageRow | None:
     """Return the persistent row of ``style`` that is active at time ``t``.
 
     A persistent row is "active" at ``t`` when its own ``timestamp`` is the
-    most recent one ``<= t`` for the given ``style``/``role``/``tool_name``
-    selector. ``events`` is accepted for resolver-signature uniformity but is
-    not consulted: only persistent styles are valid here.
+    most recent one ``<= t`` for the given ``style``/``role``/``tool_name``/
+    ``camera`` selector. ``events`` is accepted for resolver-signature
+    uniformity but is not consulted: only persistent styles are valid here.
     """
     _validate_persistent_resolver("active_at", style)
-    matches = _matching_rows(persistent, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name)
+    matches = _matching_rows(
+        persistent, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name, camera=camera
+    )
     matches = [row for row in matches if _timestamp(row) <= t]
-    return _select_latest(matches, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name)
+    return _select_latest(
+        matches, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name, camera=camera
+    )
 
 
 def emitted_at(
@@ -68,26 +73,45 @@ def emitted_at(
     style: str | None = None,
     role: str | None = None,
     tool_name: str | None = None,
+    camera: str | None = None,
 ) -> LanguageRow | None:
     """Return the row of ``style`` emitted at exactly time ``t``.
 
     For persistent styles, this matches persistent rows whose own ``timestamp``
     equals ``t``. For event styles, the ``events`` list is assumed to come from
     the dataset row at frame ``t`` (event rows carry no timestamp of their own),
-    so all matching event rows are considered emitted at ``t``.
+    so all matching event rows are considered emitted at ``t``. ``camera``
+    filters by the row's ``camera`` field — required to disambiguate when
+    multiple view-dependent rows share ``(t, role)`` across cameras.
     """
     column = column_for_style(style)
     if column == LANGUAGE_PERSISTENT:
         matches = [
             row
-            for row in _matching_rows(persistent, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name)
+            for row in _matching_rows(
+                persistent, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name, camera=camera
+            )
             if _timestamp(row) == t
         ]
         return _select_one(
-            matches, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name, sort_key=_persistent_sort_key
+            matches,
+            style=style,
+            role=role,
+            tool_name=tool_name,
+            camera=camera,
+            sort_key=_persistent_sort_key,
         )
-    matches = _matching_rows(events, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name)
-    return _select_one(matches, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name, sort_key=_event_sort_key)
+    matches = _matching_rows(
+        events, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name, camera=camera
+    )
+    return _select_one(
+        matches,
+        style=style,
+        role=role,
+        tool_name=tool_name,
+        camera=camera,
+        sort_key=_event_sort_key,
+    )
 
 
 def nth_prev(
@@ -99,12 +123,14 @@ def nth_prev(
     offset: int = 1,
     role: str | None = None,
     tool_name: str | None = None,
+    camera: str | None = None,
 ) -> LanguageRow | None:
     """Return the persistent row that was active ``offset`` steps before ``t``.
 
     Walks back through chronologically sorted persistent rows of ``style``
-    (filtered by optional ``role``/``tool_name``) and returns the one ``offset``
-    positions before the row active at ``t``. Only valid for persistent styles.
+    (filtered by optional ``role``/``tool_name``/``camera``) and returns the
+    one ``offset`` positions before the row active at ``t``. Only valid for
+    persistent styles.
     """
     return _nth_relative(
         t,
@@ -113,6 +139,7 @@ def nth_prev(
         offset=-offset,
         role=role,
         tool_name=tool_name,
+        camera=camera,
         resolver_name="nth_prev",
     )
 
@@ -126,12 +153,14 @@ def nth_next(
     offset: int = 1,
     role: str | None = None,
     tool_name: str | None = None,
+    camera: str | None = None,
 ) -> LanguageRow | None:
     """Return the persistent row that becomes active ``offset`` steps after ``t``.
 
     Walks forward through chronologically sorted persistent rows of ``style``
-    (filtered by optional ``role``/``tool_name``) and returns the one ``offset``
-    positions after the row active at ``t``. Only valid for persistent styles.
+    (filtered by optional ``role``/``tool_name``/``camera``) and returns the
+    one ``offset`` positions after the row active at ``t``. Only valid for
+    persistent styles.
     """
     return _nth_relative(
         t,
@@ -140,6 +169,7 @@ def nth_next(
         offset=offset,
         role=role,
         tool_name=tool_name,
+        camera=camera,
         resolver_name="nth_next",
     )
 
@@ -376,6 +406,7 @@ def _nth_relative(
     offset: int,
     role: str | None,
     tool_name: str | None,
+    camera: str | None,
     resolver_name: str,
 ) -> LanguageRow | None:
     """Shared body for ``nth_prev`` / ``nth_next`` with signed ``offset``."""
@@ -384,7 +415,7 @@ def _nth_relative(
         raise ValueError(f"{resolver_name} offset must be non-zero.")
 
     rows = sorted(
-        _matching_rows(persistent, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name),
+        _matching_rows(persistent, style=style, role=role, tool_name=tool_name, camera=camera),
         key=_persistent_sort_key,
     )
     if not rows:
@@ -420,14 +451,16 @@ def _matching_rows(
     style: str | None,
     role: str | None,
     tool_name: str | None,
+    camera: str | None,
 ) -> list[LanguageRow]:
-    """Return ``rows`` filtered by optional ``style``/``role``/``tool_name`` selectors."""
+    """Return ``rows`` filtered by optional ``style``/``role``/``tool_name``/``camera`` selectors."""
     return [
         row
         for row in rows
         if (style is None or row.get("style") == style)
         and (role is None or row.get("role") == role)
         and (tool_name is None or _row_has_tool_name(row, tool_name))
+        and (camera is None or row.get("camera") == camera)
     ]
 
 
@@ -437,6 +470,7 @@ def _select_latest(
     style: str | None,
     role: str | None,
     tool_name: str | None,
+    camera: str | None,
 ) -> LanguageRow | None:
     """Return the row tied for the latest ``timestamp`` (disambiguated by selectors)."""
     if not rows:
@@ -448,6 +482,7 @@ def _select_latest(
         style=style,
         role=role,
         tool_name=tool_name,
+        camera=camera,
         sort_key=_persistent_sort_key,
     )
 
@@ -458,14 +493,16 @@ def _select_one(
     style: str | None,
     role: str | None,
     tool_name: str | None,
+    camera: str | None,
     sort_key: Any,
 ) -> LanguageRow | None:
     """Return the single matching row, or raise if the selectors are ambiguous."""
     if not rows:
         return None
-    if len(rows) > 1 and role is None and tool_name is None:
+    if len(rows) > 1 and role is None and tool_name is None and camera is None:
         raise ValueError(
-            f"Ambiguous resolver for style={style!r}; add role=... or tool_name=... to disambiguate."
+            f"Ambiguous resolver for style={style!r}; add role=..., tool_name=..., "
+            f"or camera=... to disambiguate."
         )
     return sorted(rows, key=sort_key)[0]
 

tests/configs/test_recipe.py

@@ -26,6 +26,7 @@ def test_canonical_recipe_loads():
         "user_interjection_response",
         "high_level_subtask",
         "low_level_execution",
-        "ask_vqa",
+        "ask_vqa_top",
+        "ask_vqa_wrist",
     }
     assert sum(component.weight for component in recipe.blend.values()) == pytest.approx(0.96)

tests/datasets/test_language.py

@@ -13,10 +13,13 @@ from lerobot.datasets.language import (
     LANGUAGE_PERSISTENT,
     PERSISTENT_STYLES,
     STYLE_REGISTRY,
+    VIEW_DEPENDENT_STYLES,
     column_for_style,
+    is_view_dependent_style,
     language_events_arrow_type,
     language_feature_info,
     language_persistent_arrow_type,
+    validate_camera_field,
 )
 from lerobot.datasets.utils import DEFAULT_DATA_PATH
 
@@ -26,10 +29,17 @@ def test_language_arrow_schema_has_expected_fields():
     event_row_type = language_events_arrow_type().value_type
 
     assert isinstance(persistent_row_type, pa.StructType)
-    assert persistent_row_type.names == ["role", "content", "style", "timestamp", "tool_calls"]
+    assert persistent_row_type.names == [
+        "role",
+        "content",
+        "style",
+        "timestamp",
+        "camera",
+        "tool_calls",
+    ]
 
     assert isinstance(event_row_type, pa.StructType)
-    assert event_row_type.names == ["role", "content", "style", "tool_calls"]
+    assert event_row_type.names == ["role", "content", "style", "camera", "tool_calls"]
 
 
 def test_style_registry_routes_columns():
@@ -47,6 +57,46 @@ def test_style_registry_routes_columns():
     assert column_for_style(None) == LANGUAGE_EVENTS
 
 
+def test_view_dependent_styles():
+    # motion lives in PERSISTENT_STYLES and is described in robot-frame
+    # (joint / Cartesian) terms, so it is NOT view-dependent. Only vqa
+    # (event) and trace (event, pixel-trajectory) carry a camera tag.
+    assert {"vqa", "trace"} == VIEW_DEPENDENT_STYLES
+    assert is_view_dependent_style("vqa")
+    assert is_view_dependent_style("trace")
+    assert not is_view_dependent_style("motion")
+    assert not is_view_dependent_style("subtask")
+    assert not is_view_dependent_style("plan")
+    assert not is_view_dependent_style("interjection")
+    assert not is_view_dependent_style(None)
+
+
+def test_validate_camera_field_requires_camera_for_view_dependent_styles():
+    validate_camera_field("vqa", "observation.images.top")
+    validate_camera_field("trace", "observation.images.front")
+    with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="view-dependent"):
+        validate_camera_field("vqa", None)
+    with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="view-dependent"):
+        validate_camera_field("trace", "")
+
+
+def test_validate_camera_field_rejects_camera_on_non_view_dependent_styles():
+    validate_camera_field("subtask", None)
+    validate_camera_field("plan", None)
+    validate_camera_field("memory", None)
+    validate_camera_field("motion", None)
+    validate_camera_field("interjection", None)
+    validate_camera_field(None, None)
+    with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="must have camera=None"):
+        validate_camera_field("subtask", "observation.images.top")
+    with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="must have camera=None"):
+        validate_camera_field("motion", "observation.images.top")
+    with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="must have camera=None"):
+        validate_camera_field("interjection", "observation.images.top")
+    with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="must have camera=None"):
+        validate_camera_field(None, "observation.images.top")
+
+
 def test_unknown_style_rejected():
     with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Unknown language style"):
         column_for_style("surprise")
@@ -70,6 +120,7 @@ def test_lerobot_dataset_passes_language_columns_through(tmp_path, empty_lerobot
             "content": "reach for the cup",
             "style": "subtask",
             "timestamp": 0.0,
+            "camera": None,
             "tool_calls": None,
         }
     ]
@@ -77,6 +128,7 @@ def test_lerobot_dataset_passes_language_columns_through(tmp_path, empty_lerobot
         "role": "user",
         "content": "what is visible?",
         "style": "vqa",
+        "camera": "observation.images.top",
         "tool_calls": None,
     }
     data_path = root / DEFAULT_DATA_PATH.format(chunk_index=0, file_index=0)

tests/datasets/test_language_render.py

@@ -8,21 +8,23 @@ from lerobot.configs.recipe import MessageTurn, TrainingRecipe
 from lerobot.datasets.language_render import active_at, emitted_at, nth_next, nth_prev, render_sample
 
 
-def persistent_row(role, content, style, timestamp, tool_calls=None):
+def persistent_row(role, content, style, timestamp, tool_calls=None, camera=None):
     return {
         "role": role,
         "content": content,
         "style": style,
         "timestamp": timestamp,
+        "camera": camera,
         "tool_calls": tool_calls,
     }
 
 
-def event_row(role, content, style, tool_calls=None):
+def event_row(role, content, style, tool_calls=None, camera=None):
     return {
         "role": role,
         "content": content,
         "style": style,
+        "camera": camera,
         "tool_calls": tool_calls,
     }
 
@@ -35,8 +37,8 @@ PERSISTENT = [
     persistent_row("assistant", "subtask 1", "subtask", 1.0),
 ]
 EVENTS_AT_1 = [
-    event_row("user", "what is visible?", "vqa"),
-    event_row("assistant", '{"count": 2}', "vqa"),
+    event_row("user", "what is visible?", "vqa", camera="observation.images.top"),
+    event_row("assistant", '{"count": 2}', "vqa", camera="observation.images.top"),
 ]
 EVENTS_AT_2 = [
     event_row("user", "skip wiping", "interjection"),
@@ -47,6 +49,15 @@ EVENTS_AT_2 = [
         [{"type": "function", "function": {"name": "say", "arguments": {"text": "Skipping wiping."}}}],
     ),
 ]
+# Same emission tick, two cameras: triggers per-camera disambiguation in
+# resolvers, mirroring how Module 3 of the annotation pipeline writes one
+# (vqa, user) + (vqa, assistant) pair per camera.
+EVENTS_AT_3_TWO_CAMERAS = [
+    event_row("user", "how many cups (top)?", "vqa", camera="observation.images.top"),
+    event_row("assistant", '{"count": 3}', "vqa", camera="observation.images.top"),
+    event_row("user", "how many cups (wrist)?", "vqa", camera="observation.images.wrist"),
+    event_row("assistant", '{"count": 1}', "vqa", camera="observation.images.wrist"),
+]
 
 
 def test_resolver_temporal_semantics():
@@ -158,6 +169,126 @@ def test_deterministic_blend_sampling():
     assert first == second
 
 
+def test_emitted_at_filters_vqa_by_camera():
+    top = emitted_at(
+        3.0,
+        persistent=PERSISTENT,
+        events=EVENTS_AT_3_TWO_CAMERAS,
+        style="vqa",
+        role="assistant",
+        camera="observation.images.top",
+    )
+    wrist = emitted_at(
+        3.0,
+        persistent=PERSISTENT,
+        events=EVENTS_AT_3_TWO_CAMERAS,
+        style="vqa",
+        role="assistant",
+        camera="observation.images.wrist",
+    )
+    assert top["content"] == '{"count": 3}'
+    assert wrist["content"] == '{"count": 1}'
+
+
+def test_emitted_at_raises_on_ambiguous_per_camera_vqa():
+    with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Ambiguous resolver"):
+        emitted_at(
+            3.0,
+            persistent=PERSISTENT,
+            events=EVENTS_AT_3_TWO_CAMERAS,
+            style="vqa",
+            role="assistant",
+        )
+
+
+def test_per_camera_blend_renders_both_views():
+    recipe = TrainingRecipe(
+        blend={
+            "top": TrainingRecipe(
+                weight=1.0,
+                bindings={
+                    "vqa_query": (
+                        "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=user, camera=observation.images.top)"
+                    ),
+                    "vqa": (
+                        "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=assistant, camera=observation.images.top)"
+                    ),
+                },
+                messages=[
+                    MessageTurn(
+                        role="user",
+                        content=[
+                            {"type": "image", "feature": "observation.images.top"},
+                            {"type": "text", "text": "${vqa_query}"},
+                        ],
+                        stream="high_level",
+                        if_present="vqa_query",
+                    ),
+                    MessageTurn(
+                        role="assistant",
+                        content="${vqa}",
+                        stream="high_level",
+                        target=True,
+                        if_present="vqa",
+                    ),
+                ],
+            ),
+            "wrist": TrainingRecipe(
+                weight=1.0,
+                bindings={
+                    "vqa_query": (
+                        "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=user, camera=observation.images.wrist)"
+                    ),
+                    "vqa": (
+                        "emitted_at(t, style=vqa, role=assistant, camera=observation.images.wrist)"
+                    ),
+                },
+                messages=[
+                    MessageTurn(
+                        role="user",
+                        content=[
+                            {"type": "image", "feature": "observation.images.wrist"},
+                            {"type": "text", "text": "${vqa_query}"},
+                        ],
+                        stream="high_level",
+                        if_present="vqa_query",
+                    ),
+                    MessageTurn(
+                        role="assistant",
+                        content="${vqa}",
+                        stream="high_level",
+                        target=True,
+                        if_present="vqa",
+                    ),
+                ],
+            ),
+        }
+    )
+
+    rendered_top = render_sample(
+        recipe=recipe.blend["top"],
+        persistent=PERSISTENT,
+        events=EVENTS_AT_3_TWO_CAMERAS,
+        t=3.0,
+        sample_idx=0,
+    )
+    rendered_wrist = render_sample(
+        recipe=recipe.blend["wrist"],
+        persistent=PERSISTENT,
+        events=EVENTS_AT_3_TWO_CAMERAS,
+        t=3.0,
+        sample_idx=0,
+    )
+
+    assert rendered_top["messages"][0]["content"][0]["feature"] == "observation.images.top"
+    assert rendered_top["messages"][0]["content"][1]["text"] == "how many cups (top)?"
+    assert rendered_top["messages"][1]["content"] == '{"count": 3}'
+
+    assert rendered_wrist["messages"][0]["content"][0]["feature"] == "observation.images.wrist"
+    assert rendered_wrist["messages"][0]["content"][1]["text"] == "how many cups (wrist)?"
+    assert rendered_wrist["messages"][1]["content"] == '{"count": 1}'
+
+
 def test_canonical_recipe_can_render_low_level_branch():
     recipe = TrainingRecipe.from_yaml(Path("src/lerobot/configs/recipes/pi05_hirobot.yaml"))
     low_level = TrainingRecipe(blend={"low": recipe.blend["low_level_execution"]})

tests/processor/test_render_messages_processor.py

@@ -38,6 +38,7 @@ def test_render_messages_step_renders_and_drops_raw_language():
                     "content": "reach carefully",
                     "style": "subtask",
                     "timestamp": 0.0,
+                    "camera": None,
                     "tool_calls": None,
                 }
             ],